Jump to content


Sir Rols

Member Since 04 Jun 2004
Offline Last Active Today, 12:50 AM
****-

Posts I've Made

In Topic: 2019 Asian Games

Yesterday, 09:26 PM

View Postintoronto1125, on 08 February 2012 - 09:23 PM, said:

The USA does not send its best athletes in swimming athletics etc. which are sports which are not olympic qualifiers. Field hockey, Water polo, modern pentathlon etc. send their best athletes.

The fact is the reason why the Asian games have 9000+ athletes is there is no qualification involved, hence anyone can compete for ex. Maldives women's basketball team which lost by 122 points at the Asian Games. Fact is they likely would not have qualified.

Mate, you're Canadian and they're in your home town, of course you'd like the think they're the second biggest show on earth. Fair enough. But I just can't think of any criteria where they could have any claim to "sloppy seconds". Internationally, I really do think the Asiads are a bigger deal, but as I said, it's all to do with perceptions - I don't think you can come up with a "correct" answer. It's almost as futile as that other "big" debate - the world's biggest sports event full stop - Olympics or FIFA WC?

In Topic: 2019 Asian Games

Yesterday, 09:13 PM

View Postintoronto1125, on 08 February 2012 - 09:07 PM, said:

Thats one source here is another that mention the Pan Ams.

"The Pan American Games are the world's second largest international multisport event behind the Olympic Games."

http://www.insidethe...permanent-venue

Whatever - it will always be a topic for debate, and there's probably no right answer. Personally, I'd count the Asiad, the numbers are clear with that. Olympic qualifying at the Pan Ams still doesn't attract the USA's best, or get them much broadcasting attention there.

And, yeah, Baron's right earlier (I remember when we all thrashed this out years ago) - on sheer numbers, the Gay Games actually beats even the Olympics.

In Topic: 2019 Asian Games

Yesterday, 09:00 PM

View Postintoronto1125, on 07 February 2012 - 10:58 PM, said:

What makes you think the Asiad is the second biggest event. In terms of events its the biggest and athletes. However other media report the Commonwealth Games and event the Pan Ams are the second largest event.

Sorry to hark back to this, but I couldn't remember who was hosting the next Asiad, so I looked it up on Wikipedia (it's Incheon 2014, BTW), and lo and behold, Wiki lists the Asiad as the second biggest event after the Olympics:
Asian games - Wikipedia

In Topic: 2020 Inappropriate Host Competition

Yesterday, 06:14 PM

As I said in one of the CWGs threads - Abuja is wet, willing and waiting!

In Topic: Canada 2022

Yesterday, 05:41 PM

View Postintoronto1125, on 08 February 2012 - 05:32 PM, said:

Malaysia? Interesting I think they might have confused it with Singapore.

I didn't notice that, but it could well be right. The Malaysians always have been more keen to go after such events than the Singaporeans. I wouldn't be surprised if they fancied KL's chances for a second tilt.

But what about the great hole in Africa??? It's wet, willing and waiting!